Franchise Rankings

Best Mystery Island Collection Movies Ranked

Explore the best mystery island collection movies ranked by Movie Rankings users. Our current #1 pick is Mystery Island. Browse 4 franchise titles in ranked order, with direct links to movie pages and matchup data.

collection of 'Mystery Island' Hallmark’s Movie

Ranked Franchise Movies
Franchise rank #1

Mystery Island (2023)

Open the movie page for cast, crew, ranking, and matchup detail.

Franchise rank #2

Mystery Island: Winner Takes All (2025)

Open the movie page for cast, crew, ranking, and matchup detail.

Franchise rank #3

Mystery Island: Play for Keeps (2025)

Open the movie page for cast, crew, ranking, and matchup detail.

Franchise rank #4

Mystery Island: House Rules (2025)

Open the movie page for cast, crew, ranking, and matchup detail.

Quick Answers

What is the best movie in the mystery island collection?

Mystery Island is currently the highest-ranked movie in the Mystery Island Collection on Movie Rankings based on aggregate head-to-head results from the community.

How many mystery island collection movies are ranked here?

This page currently tracks 4 movies in the Mystery Island Collection.

How often do the mystery island collection rankings update?

The mystery island collection rankings refresh whenever Movie Rankings recomputes global results. This page was last generated from site data on recently.

Explore More Rankings

Best English TV Movie Movies of 2023

See how Mystery Island compares with other top-ranked english tv movie movies from 2023.

Best English Mystery Movies of 2023

See how Mystery Island compares with other top-ranked english mystery movies from 2023.

Best English TV Movie Movies

See how Mystery Island compares with other top-ranked english tv movie movies.

Best English Mystery Movies

See how Mystery Island compares with other top-ranked english mystery movies.

Best English Movies of 2023

See how Mystery Island compares with other top-ranked english movies from 2023.

Best English Movies

See how Mystery Island compares with other top-ranked english movies.

Best TV Movie Movies of 2023

See how Mystery Island compares with other top-ranked 2023 tv movie movies.

Best Mystery Movies of 2023

See how Mystery Island compares with other top-ranked 2023 mystery movies.

Best The Cartel Movies

Browse more top-ranked movies associated with The Cartel.

Best English Mystery Movies of 2025

See how Mystery Island: Winner Takes All compares with other top-ranked english mystery movies from 2025.

Best English TV Movie Movies of 2025

See how Mystery Island: Winner Takes All compares with other top-ranked english tv movie movies from 2025.

Best English Movies of 2025

See how Mystery Island: Winner Takes All compares with other top-ranked english movies from 2025.

Best Mystery Movies of 2025

See how Mystery Island: Winner Takes All compares with other top-ranked 2025 mystery movies.

Best TV Movie Movies of 2025

See how Mystery Island: Winner Takes All compares with other top-ranked 2025 tv movie movies.

Best English Adventure Movies of 2025

See how Mystery Island: Play for Keeps compares with other top-ranked english adventure movies from 2025.

Best English Adventure Movies

See how Mystery Island: Play for Keeps compares with other top-ranked english adventure movies.

Best Adventure Movies of 2025

See how Mystery Island: Play for Keeps compares with other top-ranked 2025 adventure movies.

Best English Crime Movies of 2025

See how Mystery Island: House Rules compares with other top-ranked english crime movies from 2025.

Best English Crime Movies

See how Mystery Island: House Rules compares with other top-ranked english crime movies.

Best Crime Movies of 2025

See how Mystery Island: House Rules compares with other top-ranked 2025 crime movies.

Best Hallmark Media Movies

Browse more top-ranked movies associated with Hallmark Media.

Best Elizabeth Henstridge Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Elizabeth Henstridge, one of the main cast members in Mystery Island.

Best Charlie Weber Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Charlie Weber, one of the main cast members in Mystery Island.

Best Kezia Burrows Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Kezia Burrows, one of the main cast members in Mystery Island.

Best Robert Getman Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Robert Getman, one of the main cast members in Mystery Island.

Best Kristin Booth Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Kristin Booth, one of the main cast members in Mystery Island: Winner Takes All.

Best Emily Eaton-Plowright Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Emily Eaton-Plowright, one of the main cast members in Mystery Island: Play for Keeps.

Best Francisco Labbe Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Francisco Labbe, one of the main cast members in Mystery Island: House Rules.

Sources & freshness

Last refreshed from site data on recently.

TMDB collection metadata

Franchise membership, poster art, and release-order metadata are sourced from TMDB collections.

Movie Rankings comparisons

Community comparison results determine which franchise movies rank highest on Movie Rankings.