A Costly Choice
Directed by Ricky Greenwood
Selena (Sarah Arabic) is married to Eric (Isiah Maxwell). But one day, Selena has a chance encounter with a delivery woman, Katie (Lily LaBeau), and sparks fly. Selena realizes that she's not straight, and this leads to a secret affair with Katie. But things get serious and Selena decides she wants to divorce Eric since it's not fair to any of them. When Eric returns home, Selena gives him the divorce papers. She has Katie by her side, revealing that she's been having an affair, and Eric gets upset. Betrayed, he refuses to sign the divorce papers. The two women beg him to reconsider, and that's when he gets a sinister idea: he'll sign the papers IF the new happy couple lets him fuck them both.
Crew
Decade ranking
Explore where A Costly Choice fits among the best movies of the 2020s.
Open best movies of the 2020s
Studio ranking
See where A Costly Choice lands among the top-ranked movies associated with Pure Taboo.
Open best pure taboo movies
Language ranking
See how A Costly Choice compares with other top-ranked English movies from 2026.
Open best english movies of 2026
More like this
Explore public related-title picks for viewers looking for movies like A Costly Choice.
Open movies like A Costly Choice
Where to watch
Open the answer-first viewing guide for A Costly Choice, including current streaming, rental, and purchase options.
Open where to watch A Costly Choice
