Genre Rankings

Best Mystery Movies Ranked

Explore the best mystery movies ranked by Movie Rankings users. Our current #1 pick is The Batman. Browse 28 ranked mystery movies, with direct links to cast, crew, and matchup data.

Current #1
The Batman
Ranked titles
28
Last refreshed
May 4, 2026
ActionAdventureAnimationComedyCrimeDramaFamilyFantasyHistoryHorrorMusicMysteryRomanceScience FictionThrillerWarWestern
Top Ranked Mystery Movies
1
The Batman
2022·6 votes·5W-1L·83% win rate
Rating
1559
2
The Prestige
2006·11 votes·8W-3L·73% win rate
Rating
1557
3
The Bourne Identity
2002·5 votes·4W-1L·80% win rate
Rating
1552
5
The Da Vinci Code
2006·3 votes·3W-0L·100% win rate
Rating
1552
6
Limitless
2011·2 votes·2W-0L·100% win rate
Rating
1535
7
Sherlock Holmes
2009·4 votes·3W-1L·75% win rate
Rating
1535
8
Zootopia 2
2025·1 votes·1W-0L·100% win rate
Rating
1521
9
Shutter Island
2010·9 votes·5W-4L·56% win rate
Rating
1507
10
National Treasure: Book of Secrets
2007·4 votes·2W-2L·50% win rate
Rating
1500
11
Watchmen
2009·2 votes·1W-1L·50% win rate
Rating
1500
12
The Bourne Ultimatum
2007·2 votes·1W-1L·50% win rate
Rating
1500
13
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
2011·2 votes·1W-1L·50% win rate
Rating
1500
14
The Sixth Sense
1999·2 votes·1W-1L·50% win rate
Rating
1500
15
Angels & Demons
2009·4 votes·2W-2L·50% win rate
Rating
1500
16
Enola Holmes
2020·4 votes·2W-2L·50% win rate
Rating
1500
17
Scooby-Doo
2002·4 votes·2W-2L·50% win rate
Rating
1498
18
Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery
2025·4 votes·2W-2L·50% win rate
Rating
1497
19
The Hateful Eight
2015·2 votes·1W-1L·50% win rate
Rating
1497
20
Memento
2000·3 votes·1W-2L·33% win rate
Rating
1483
21
Murder on the Orient Express
2017·5 votes·2W-3L·40% win rate
Rating
1482
22
Knives Out
2019·2 votes·0W-2L·0% win rate
Rating
1465
23
Gone Girl
2014·3 votes·0W-3L·0% win rate
Rating
1448
24
Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery
2022·5 votes·1W-4L·20% win rate
Rating
1447
25
Citizen Kane
1941·4 votes·0W-4L·0% win rate
Rating
1429
26
The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones
2013·4 votes·0W-4L·0% win rate
Rating
1428
27
Now You See Me: Now You Don't
2025·12 votes·3W-9L·25% win rate
Rating
1386
28
The Maze Runner
2014·8 votes·0W-8L·0% win rate
Rating
1354

What is the best mystery movie?

The Batman is currently the highest-ranked mystery movie on Movie Rankings based on aggregate head-to-head results from the community.

How many mystery movies are ranked here?

This page currently tracks 28 ranked mystery movies.

How often do the mystery rankings update?

The mystery rankings refresh whenever Movie Rankings recomputes global results. This page was last generated from site data on May 4, 2026.

Explore More Rankings

Best The Batman Collection Movies

See where The Batman lands inside the ranked The Batman Collection.

Best 6th & Idaho Motion Picture Company Movies

Browse more top-ranked movies associated with 6th & Idaho Motion Picture Company.

Best Crime Movies on Max

See how The Batman compares with other top-ranked crime movies we currently surface on Max.

Best Mystery Movies on Max

See how The Batman compares with other top-ranked mystery movies we currently surface on Max.

Best Thriller Movies on Max

See how The Batman compares with other top-ranked thriller movies we currently surface on Max.

Best Movies on Max

See how The Batman compares with other top-ranked movies we currently surface on Max.

Best Warner Bros. Pictures Movies

Browse more top-ranked movies associated with Warner Bros. Pictures.

Best Drama Movies on Hulu

See how The Prestige compares with other top-ranked drama movies we currently surface on Hulu.

Best Mystery Movies on Hulu

See how The Prestige compares with other top-ranked mystery movies we currently surface on Hulu.

Best Science Fiction Movies on Hulu

See how The Prestige compares with other top-ranked science fiction movies we currently surface on Hulu.

Best Movies on Hulu

See how The Prestige compares with other top-ranked movies we currently surface on Hulu.

Best The Bourne Collection Movies

See where The Bourne Identity lands inside the ranked The Bourne Collection.

Best Universal Pictures Movies

Browse more top-ranked movies associated with Universal Pictures.

Best Robert Langdon Collection Movies

See where The Da Vinci Code lands inside the ranked Robert Langdon Collection.

Best Imagine Entertainment Movies

Browse more top-ranked movies associated with Imagine Entertainment.

Best Relativity Media Movies

Browse more top-ranked movies associated with Relativity Media.

Best Thriller Movies on Amazon Prime Video

See how Limitless compares with other top-ranked thriller movies we currently surface on Amazon Prime Video.

Best Mystery Movies on Amazon Prime Video

See how Limitless compares with other top-ranked mystery movies we currently surface on Amazon Prime Video.

Best Science Fiction Movies on Amazon Prime Video

See how Limitless compares with other top-ranked science fiction movies we currently surface on Amazon Prime Video.

Best Movies on Amazon Prime Video

See how Limitless compares with other top-ranked movies we currently surface on Amazon Prime Video.

Best Thriller Movies on Peacock

See how Limitless compares with other top-ranked thriller movies we currently surface on Peacock.

Best Mystery Movies on Peacock

See how Limitless compares with other top-ranked mystery movies we currently surface on Peacock.

Best Science Fiction Movies on Peacock

See how Limitless compares with other top-ranked science fiction movies we currently surface on Peacock.

Best Movies on Peacock

See how Limitless compares with other top-ranked movies we currently surface on Peacock.

Best Sherlock Holmes Collection Movies

See where Sherlock Holmes lands inside the ranked Sherlock Holmes Collection.

Best Robert Pattinson Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Robert Pattinson, one of the main cast members in The Batman.

Best Zoë Kravitz Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Zoë Kravitz, one of the main cast members in The Batman.

Best Jeffrey Wright Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Jeffrey Wright, one of the main cast members in The Batman.

Best Colin Farrell Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Colin Farrell, one of the main cast members in The Batman.

Best Hugh Jackman Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Hugh Jackman, one of the main cast members in The Prestige.

Best Christian Bale Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Christian Bale, one of the main cast members in The Prestige.

Best Michael Caine Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Michael Caine, one of the main cast members in The Prestige.

Best Piper Perabo Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Piper Perabo, one of the main cast members in The Prestige.

Best Matt Damon Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Matt Damon, one of the main cast members in The Bourne Identity.

Best Franka Potente Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Franka Potente, one of the main cast members in The Bourne Identity.

Best Chris Cooper Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Chris Cooper, one of the main cast members in The Bourne Identity.

Best Clive Owen Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Clive Owen, one of the main cast members in The Bourne Identity.

Best Tom Hanks Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Tom Hanks, one of the main cast members in The Da Vinci Code.

Best Audrey Tautou Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Audrey Tautou, one of the main cast members in The Da Vinci Code.

Best Ian McKellen Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Ian McKellen, one of the main cast members in The Da Vinci Code.

Best Jean Reno Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Jean Reno, one of the main cast members in The Da Vinci Code.

Best Bradley Cooper Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Bradley Cooper, one of the main cast members in Limitless.

Best Robert De Niro Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Robert De Niro, one of the main cast members in Limitless.

Best Abbie Cornish Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Abbie Cornish, one of the main cast members in Limitless.

Best Andrew Howard Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Andrew Howard, one of the main cast members in Limitless.

Best Robert Downey Jr. Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Robert Downey Jr., one of the main cast members in Sherlock Holmes.

Best Jude Law Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Jude Law, one of the main cast members in Sherlock Holmes.

Best Rachel McAdams Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Rachel McAdams, one of the main cast members in Sherlock Holmes.

Best Mark Strong Movies

Explore ranked movie pages featuring Mark Strong, one of the main cast members in Sherlock Holmes.

Sources & freshness

Last refreshed from site data on May 4, 2026.

TMDB catalog metadata

Movie titles, poster assets, release dates, and genre metadata across ranked entries are sourced from TMDB.

Movie Rankings comparisons

Global ranks, win-loss records, and aggregate scores come from Movie Rankings users.